April 15, 2013 posted by Chuck Anderson

Added and Dropped: Catcher Carosel

Added and Dropped:  Catcher Carosel
Print Friendly

It is a traditionally weak spot on fantasy teams but the catcher position was touted as being relatively deep in 2013.  Supporting that theory, two backstops well off the radar are among the league’s home run leaders.  The rush to own these hot hitters rendered some early slumpers expendable.




John Buck:  Entering Sunday’s action he was one of five players with six home runs.  He owns legitimate power but is a career .236 hitter.   He is increasing his fly ball rate like Brandon Moss did last year.  He could reach twenty home runs for the second time in his career given this start.

Drop for him:  Chris Iannetta, A.J. Ellis, Jarrod Saltalamacchia

Don’t drop for him:  Victor Martinez, Salvador Perez, Carlos Santana

Evan Gattis:  Saturday’s hero will get plenty of playing time as long as Brian McCann and Freddie Freeman are out.  We have precious few plate appearances to analyze, but he showed “power and reasonable plate discipline” in the minors.  He appears slightly chase-happy and it would be wise to not totally buy in until he makes more than one trip around the league.

Drop for him:  Ryan Doumit, Brian McCann, Wellington Castillo

Don’t drop for him:  Carlos Ruiz, Nick Hundley, Mike Napoli

Justin Masterson:  A less than stellar 2012 pushed him to the fringes of mixed league consideration, but he is back on the map after allowing one run in three starts.  His strikeout rate is up, but there is not enough of a change in contact rate to believe it will stay above his established level.  He is worth owning, but do not start him if the opposition can stack their lineup with quality left-handed batters.

Drop for him:  Tim Lincecum, Derek Holland, Jeremy Hellickson

Don’t drop for him:  Hiroki Kuroda, Homer Bailey, Jose Fernandez


Barry Zito:  He is off to a strong start in 2013, throwing fourteen scoreless innings.  He features a Jaime Moyer-esque 83 mph fastball, but is controlling it well.  His walk rate is down and he is getting strike one on 60.4% of at bats.  His strikeout rate remains very low. The low K-rate hurts him for fantasy purposes and also makes it tough to project an ERA under 4.00.

Drop for him:  Jarrod Parker, Ryan Vogelsong, Josh Beckett

Don’t drop for him:  Marco Estrada, Roy Halladay, Dan Haren


Jesus Montero, DH, Seattle Mariners

Jesus Montero, DH, Seattle Mariners



Jesus Montero:  He showed progress in the second half of 2012, but is starting 2013 with a thud.  He was benched three times in the last five games in favor of Kelly Shoppach.  He finished as the twelfth ranked catcher last year, but he faces better competition and must improve or become irrelevant in standard leagues.

Drop him for:  J.P. Arencibia, Jonathan Lucroy, John Jaso

Don’t drop him for:  Alex Avila, Tyler Flowers, Russell Martin


Jonathan Lucroy:  The scuffling catcher was given two days off in the last four.  His BB/K numbers and plate discipline rates are steady, so he should rebound soon.  He hit .361 with men on base last year.  He will not repeat that, so his run production will decrease.

Drop him for:  John Buck, Jarrod Saltalamacchia, A.J. Pierzynski

Don’t drop him for:  Ryan Doumit, Wilson Ramos, Jose Molina


Cameron Maybin:  Two weeks of action is not enough to downgrade a player, but Maybin was terrible last year too.  In deeper leagues there is probably nobody on the wire with his pure tools but those in standard leagues can cut him without remorse.

Drop him for:  Justin Maxwell, Denard Span, Starling Marte

Don’t drop him for:  Jackie Bradley Jr., Matt Joyce, Drew Stubbs


Brandon McCarthy:  He was shelled in both his starts and only struck out five in 11.2 IP.  The numbers suggest his command (not control) is failing him.  He is walking only 1.54/9 and has an 80.7% first strike rate.  However, he is giving up line drives 28.3% of the time and hitters are connecting on 89.8% of swings.  He should come around in time, but there is no need to stash him and wait.

Drop him for:  Ervin Santana, Ross Detwiler, A.J. Griffin

Don’t drop him for:  Phil Hughes, Julio Teheran, J.A. Happ



You must be logged in to post a comment.